Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters
A former JPMorgan VP who counsels female bankers says it's hard.

"Banks are full of beautiful successful women with dating issues"

It's Valentine's Day and if you haven't spent the equivalent of at least $175 on your chosen one, you're falling behind. But if you're a woman in investment banking, buying lavish gifts can be problematic. 

"Men will say they want a powerful woman who earns more than them, but the feedback that I hear from a lot of my female clients is that when they're in a dating situation, this isn't the case," says Lucy Puttergill, the former JPMorgan VP in delta one sales who left banking to travel the world and become a coach in 2020. Research has shown that men don't like women who earn more than them. "There's a big issue around women in banking and dating," Puttergill observes, "It's really difficult for them."

Puttergill, who is currently in Cape Town, works with a lot of female bankers. She says dating is their number one issue. "I cannot tell you how many beautiful hugely successful women there are in banking who feel like they've been sold a lie," she says. While many of her female clients are high achieving, high earners at work, they struggle to find partners who match them intellectually. "They feel that the only thing going right in their lives is their careers. They're in their mid-30s to 40s, they have a great job and a huge house and some want to have children, but their job takes up all of their time and there’s a sense of failure

Best comment picked by the author
Anyone this article is referring to, want to date me? 40 years old, former GS, ivy league, single dad to 7 and 8 year old beautiful daughters, live in a Scottsdale country club, good cook, clean the house, do the landscaping, handyman remodel my own stuff, scratch golfer, part time financial advisor, really want to be a full time stay at home Dad though.

Younger women in banking don't necessarily share this prognosis. One 20-something female analyst in NYC says young men in hedge funds find it "hot" when a woman is powerful and independent. "For a lot of men these days, this is the type they go for," she claims. However, she acknowledges that she recently split with a guy who was too demanding of her time: "They were in asset management and their hours were on the softer side."

Puttergill says older women in banking are often tempted to double down on their careers because of relationship problems. Single women put more and more energy into work and when they do date, they approach it with the same mentality and treat finding a partner as something to be "achieved." The work persona leaches into personal relationships: "When they meet someone, they end up pitching themselves." 

To overcome this, Puttergill helps her clients to feel comfortable acknowledging and presenting a fuller version of who they are. "A lot of people in banking have very low self-esteem," she says. "The achievement and validation that come from banking careers can hide a sense of personal inadequacy. A lot of people in banking have perfect lives and perfect personas, but underneath they feel very vulnerable. I work with people to help them take off the work mask and to see what's beheath."  

It's not simply about doing this in pursuit of a relationship, says Puttergill. "You need to reconnect with who you are beneath the high achiever identity. Make your life so full and expansive and enjoyable that meeting someone becomes the cherry on the cake rather than an achievement." 

This is the considered way of approaching dating issues. However, the female analyst in NYC is less apologetic about her approach. "I want someone accepting of my priorities" she says. "I need someone who will understand the person that I want to become, who can see that I have expertise that will allow me to be valued in the finance industry. To me that's happiness. I don't want to be at home with the kids."

Click here to create a profile on eFinancialCareers. Make yourself visible to recruiters hiring for top jobs in technology and finance. 

Have a confidential story, tip, or comment you’d like to share? Contact: in the first instance. Whatsapp/Signal/Telegram also available (Telegram: @SarahButcher)

Bear with us if you leave a comment at the bottom of this article: all our comments are moderated by human beings. Sometimes these humans might be asleep, or away from their desks, so it may take a while for your comment to appear. Eventually it will – unless it’s offensive or libelous (in which case it won’t.)


AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • Jo
    John Wick
    15 March 2023

    A beautiful woman I once knew and liked but never told them because I knew they will get to the very top and didnt want to bother them but also feared the repercussions of making them feel uncomfortable if I were to tell them


  • 14
    27 February 2023

    I am a woman with a career spanning corporate years and years as an independent contractor and small business CEO and Owner. I have found dating difficult on both my schedule and the men's schedules. When schedules allow, a good dinner at my house is an opportunity to relax and be myself with someone who can forget about pocketbook needs. On the other hand, I have had men stay 15 minutes and leave due to my "shallowness" and cite reasons such as questions regarding why I would need a man if I have already taken care of myself. I find this rather offensive. I am not above going to "his" place for a date. What is wrong with I keep myself well? I do not need men who cannot cope with women's success.

  • ph
    25 February 2023

    There are some truly bizarre responses here. Full of grammar mistakes, hatred of women or men, and total disconnect from reality.

    I would suggest that banking is a bad way to meet a life partner. Every one in the IB and related worlds (the high paid ones we're talking about) competes with every other, no one can really be trusted, nothing there that's even slightly natural. You want that type of money, you're never going to find love. At least not the romantic type. Male or female, you'll sleep around, do expensive vacations if you can get away, spend your money as fast as you can, and do absolutely nothing for your community or religion or even your family. The closest you'll get to friends will be your doorman, or fancy drink meister, or perhaps the screener at your favorite fancy but not really good eatery.

  • JA
    22 February 2023

    Hi, I am a woman working in Finance - hot - but single- in my thirties... and Yes, I was sold a lye - when my young self thought to get a man (a real one / 100% testosterones / Alpha type) I had to not only being pretty but having a great carrier - so I thought my beauty was not enough I had to work and compete with man to be his equal to get his respect and by ricochet get his love...... Today I can tell it is the biggest mistake I have done in my life - I am anti-feminist by the way. Men are very easy going, they just want a good/ feminine woman who respects them, nothing more in reality.... Also, I do not trust that men equal female - as they are 2 different species. Men have a place that is higher than women in terms of responsibility. If I could - I would just spend my twenties being hot, feminine and find a good man instead of killing my time dealing with spreadsheets.   

  • Is
    21 February 2023

    Want to know what men want in a women? Listen to Andrew Tate or other male influencers instead of some woman named Butcher who's probably single anyway. We want obedient, submissive, feminine women. Anything else is just western perversion and deviation from the norm. FFS this article starts out with some BS about men wanting women who get paid more. Yeah, sure, maybe little fairies but not men. And you had to do frickin research to find out that wasn't the case? Wake up.

Show more

Apply for jobs

Find thousands of jobs in financial services and technology by signing up to eFinancialCareers today.

Boost your career

Find thousands of job opportunities by signing up to eFinancialCareers today.
Recommended Jobs